Winter 2003, Vol. 35, No. 4
Celebrating the Wright Brothers' First Flight
The International Civil Aeronautics Conference of 1928, Part 2
By Charles F. Downs II
Orville Wright, with Wilbur watching at right, makes the historic first flight at Kitty Hawk on December 17, 1903. (165-WW-7B-6)
The delegates' next destination was Kitty Hawk, North Carolina, for ceremonies honoring the Wrights. Getting them there was a formidable logistical challenge. Paved roads ended seventy miles from Norfolk. For the rest of the trip they had to travel on sand and clay tracks, temporary "corduroy" roads, and finally the packed sand of the beaches. Motorcoach buses could take the delegates only as far as Currituck Courthouse, North Carolina. Seventy private cars then took the delegates to Point Harbor, where the Roanoke Ferry Company made a special trip directly to Kitty Hawk, which was still a mile and a half from the site of the planned activities.
Flying the delegates to Kitty Hawk was impossible. Langley's chief test pilot, Thomas Carroll, reported that although there were large expanses of level ground, "numerous and large 'sink holes' or soft spots" made it very dangerous to land an airplane. "Landings should only be made there in an emergency with little hope of taking off again."
During planning discussions, NACA had suggested the reenactment of the Wrights' first flight, using "an extremely early Wright aircraft now in the Possession of the Army" as well as demonstrations of modern army and navy airplanes. Nothing came of these proposals, not in the least because of the unavailability of any early Wright "aeros" in airworthy condition.
Once at Kitty Hawk, another assembly of private automobiles took the delegates to a North Carolina barbecue and turkey lunch as guests of the Kill Devil Hills Memorial Association. They arrived at the memorial site on the afternoon of December 17, twenty-five years to the day after the Wrights' historic flight. At two o'clock, Secretary of War Dwight F. Davis laid the cornerstone of the planned national monument at the top of the dune.
The "Pilgrimage to Kitty Hawk" was quite a trek for the delegates and other visitors. (Records of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, RG 255)
The gathering then proceeded downhill to a place that had been carefully identified by surviving eyewitnesses as the exact spot where the original Wright flight had started. Senator Hiram Bingham, president of the National Aeronautical Association, spoke and unveiled an inscribed ten-ton granite boulder to mark the site.
Amelia Earhart made the trip as an official guest rather than a delegate. In Amelia Earhart, A Biography (1989), Doris Rich writes that Earhart was delighted that she was considered an important enough personality to be a guest of the government. According to an account by local North Carolina photographer Dixon MacNeil, Earhart, accompanied by Reed Landis and the her trans-Atlantic pilot Wilmur Stulz, "commandeered" two horses and a wagon in order to make her way from the ferry to the monument site, collecting a number of other celebrities along the way, including the Russian-born aviation innovator Igor Sikorsky. Still, she managed to be standing beside Orville Wright and Senator Bingham for a widely distributed photo of the unveiling of the marker, no doubt to the approval of her publicity-conscious future husband, George Putnam.
Although he attended other conference activities, Charles Lindbergh was conspicuous by his absence from the ceremony at Kitty Hawk. He expressed his regret that he had a previous engagement in New York City. It was also said that Lindbergh believed that it was Orville Wright's day, and he did not want to take away from it by his presence.
The release of a flock of navy carrier pigeons to flutter their way home to Norfolk signaled the end of the ceremonies. The pigeons probably had a better return trip than the delegates and spectators, as their return home was compared unfavorably to Napoleon's retreat from Moscow by the New York Times reporter on the scene. If the trip to Kitty Hawk had been arduous, the return was an ordeal, when thousands of spectators tried to leave this isolated spit of sand at one time.
The delegates' final arrival in Washington, D.C., from Kitty Hawk marked the last official activity related to the conference. There is no shortage of praise for it in the files. A. B. Barber, of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, wrote MacCracken, "The Aeronautical Conference was, I feel, a great success—at least that was the unanimous reaction which I got from the delegates at the time and from others who have spoken of it."
Industry giant Chance Vought, a technical representative to the American delegation, wrote to MacCracken: "The conference was very much a success. The industry and the American public owe a great deal to you and your Department for putting it across, and I want to add my personal felicitations and congratulations for the job you did." A letter from an engineer with the General Electric Company noted that "It was a wonderful program and I know you will be pleased to have me say that it was a real inspiration to all of us."
Apparently the White House agreed. Presidential secretary F. Stuart Crawford wrote MacCracken on December 19: "I should judge the conference was a great success in every way, due, I am sure, in no small measure to your energy and ability."
As a sidelight to the official twenty-fifth anniversary observances of the Wrights' achievement, many international aeronautical organizations in the United States and worldwide held ceremonies and banquets. MacCracken had sent messages to a number of them and received letters of thanks and good wishes in return. One letter from the president of the Royal Aeronautical Society, contained a bit of irony:
The Royal Aeronautical Society held a Dinner last night in the Science Museum at South Kensington in the shadow of the wings of the original Wright Aeroplane on which twenty-five years ago the brothers Wilbur and Orville Wright made the first flights ever made by man in a power-driven aeroplane.
This sentence brought home the unwelcome truth that the actual Wright "Flyer" that had made the historic flight was in a British museum and unavailable for the observances in the United States. Orville Wright himself had loaned it to the British because of his unhappiness with what he believed was the Smithsonian Institution's failure to give him and his brother full credit for their achievement. This situation would not be resolved until after World War II, when officials of the Smithsonian placated Orville, and he allowed the Flyer to be returned to its place of honor in its homeland.
The long-term impact of the International Civil Aviation Conference in establishing the United States as the world leader in civil aviation was muted by the effects of the Depression. While the period of the 1920s and 1930s are characterized as "Aviation's Golden Age," the aviation industry faced daunting challenges over these two decades.
The Air Commerce Act of 1926 and the enthusiasm generated by Lindbergh's trans-Atlantic flight had sparked a speculative "aviation boom" in the last quarter of the 1920s, a "bubble" that was popped by the Great Depression. Much of the value of aviation stock evaporated. A weakening economy, punctuated by the stock market crash in 1929, dried up both markets and access to investment capital. Into the 1930s, the industry struggled to survive by various means, but many companies disappeared, went bankrupt, became inactive, or just scraped by on meager military contracts.
Along with much of the rest of the economy, the American aviation industry was crippled and left heavily dependent on air mail operations and export orders for survival. As even Henry Ford discovered, aviation was a notoriously difficult industry in which to make money.
Despite the problems faced by aviation as an industry, technological advances during this period were breathtaking. Designs went from wood and fabric biplanes to sleek metal monoplanes, with amazing increases in speed, range payload, and reliability. Aviation events made news, and record-breaking flights still captured the public imagination. But it was not until 1938, with defense production gearing back up, that the number of aircraft produced in the United States again approached 1928 levels.
No international agreements or conventions were produced by the conference, as none were intended. Its most lasting legacies may well be the two U.S. postage stamps issued to commemorate it. In the end, State Department officials may have correctly categorized it as "nothing but a celebration." Perhaps so, but it was still a fitting way to recognize the twenty-fifth anniversary of the day "America gave wings to the world!"*
* This phrase was used by Secretary of War Davis in his speech at Kitty Hawk, December 17, 1928, and appears on the postal cover commemorating the occasion.
Charles F. Downs II was a senior appraiser with the Life Cycle Management Division at the National Archives and Records Administration until his retirement in December 2003. He has an M.A. in history from the University of Maryland and has been an archivist at NARA since 1978. He has worked with a wide range of civil and military records, including such specialized areas as diplomatic records, still pictures, and printed archives, and has a life-long fascination with aviation.
Note on Sources
The International Civil Aeronautics Conference seems to have made little or no impression on the popular historical consciousness. More surprising, it is rarely mentioned by those specializing in the 1920s, aviation history, or even by the biographers or in the papers of the participants. While the conference merited a few references in contemporary newspapers and periodicals, its story is most completely told in the records of the federal government in the holdings of the National Archives.
The first and most obvious place to look is in the records of the Federal Aviation Administration. Although the FAA did not exist in 1928, records of its predecessor agencies are located in RG 237. The Civil Aeronautics Administration's general correspondence file, 1926–1934, contains several folders related to the conference.
References in those folders to the State Department led to that agency's records. While there is some duplication of the CAA files, these two sources together provide a wonderful, if somewhat fragmentary, insider's view of preparations for the conference.
National Archives at College Park, Maryland
Record Group 59, General Records of the Department of State, Decimal Files, Decimal 576.R1.
Record Group 237, Records of the Federal Aviation Administration, Records of the Civil Aeronautics Administration, General Correspondence, 1926–1934, File 606, International Civil Aviation Conference; File 805.30, Wright Memorial, Kitty Hawk, 1927–32.
Record Group 255, Records of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NACA "Biography" File (Correspondence, Reports and Other Records Relating to the Careers of Committee Members, 1915–58), Victory, James F., Folder "NACA Pilgrimage to Kitty Hawk, 1928." Still photographs 255-GF, folder 520, the ICAC delegates visiting the NACA Langley laboratories (three group photographs).
Record Group 342, Records of the United States Air Force, motion picture films 342-USAF-16170, "Commemorating the 40th Anniversary of the Wright Brothers First Flight," and -18082, "Wright Brothers News Clippings." These silent black-and-white films include contemporary newsreel footage of the conference, the delegates, and their excursions to Dayton and Kitty Hawk.
Hoover Presidential Library, West Branch, Iowa
William P. MacCracken Papers, box 16, folder "The International Civil Aeronautics Conference, Washington, 1928," contains correspondence and publications related to the conference.
The Commerce Department's Aeronautics Branch endeavored to publicize the conference in its own bimonthly publication, Domestic Air News. Between July 31 and December 15, 1928, issues 33, 37, 38, 41, and 42 contained information concerning the conference. Issue 44, January 15, 1929, had a two-page "review" of the conference. The next issue, January 31, 1929, noted that the proceedings had been printed and were available from the Government Printing Office (GPO).
The official publications of the conference are classified under as S 5.28 in the Superintendent of Documents (SuDocs) classification system. Because the conference's official languages were English and French, all documents appear in both languages. Publications of the "The International Civil Aviation Conference, Washington, D.C., December 12, 13, and 14, 1928," consist of: Lists and Addresses of Foreign Official and Unofficial Delegates and American Representatives (25 pp.), Proceedings of the Conference (286 pp.), Papers Submitted by the Delegates to Consideration by the Conference (669 pp.), Rules of the Conference (3 pp.), and programs for the various events. President Coolidge's address was included in the Proceedings and was published separately as Address of President Coolidge to the International Civil Aviation Conference (SuDocs Pr 30.2 In8/2).
The official description of the proceedings at Kitty Hawk appeared as House Document No. 520 (70th Congress, 2nd sess.), "Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the First Airplane Flight, Proceedings at the Exercises Held at Kitty Hawk, N.C., on December 17, 1928, In Commemoration of the Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the First Flight of an Airplane Made by Wilbur and Orville Wright," U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, 1929.
See also William R. Chapman, and Jill K. Hanson, Wright Brothers National Memorial Historic Resources Study (National Park Service, January 1997).
The controversy between Orville Wright and the Smithsonian is well documented in aviation literature. Wright's own explanation, "On Why the 1903 Wright Aeroplane is Sent to a British Museum," was published in the magazine U.S. Air Services 13 (March 1928): 30–31, and appears in The Papers of Wilbur and Orville Wright, ed. Marvin W. MacFarland (1953), vol. 2, 1906–1948, pp. 1145–1148.
The New York Times, October, November, December 1928, and January 1929. The Times ran a number of articles on the conference and related topics.
The News and Observer (Raleigh, N.C.). Leon Rooke, "The N.C. Role in Aviation: It Did Not End With the Wright Brothers," September 30, 1962, outlines the career of photographer Dixon MacNeil and his association with aviation personalities, including those at the dedication of the Wright Brothers Memorial at Kitty Hawk.
Books and Periodicals
While there is an occasional passing reference to the conference, no substantive treatment of it appears in books or periodicals.