History of the Certificate of Citizenship, 1790–1956
The demand for proof of citizenship resulted in the creation of certificates of citizenship (also called certificates of naturalization) during the “Old Law” period of United States naturalization history (March 26, 1790–September 26, 1906). Government efforts to end naturalization fraud and ensure documentation of all naturalized citizens motivated the evolution of certificates throughout the “Certificate File (C-File)” period (September 27, 1906–March 31, 1956).
“Old Law” Period (March 26, 1790–September 26, 1906)
During the “Old Law” period, there was no federal oversight for the issuance of certificates of citizenship (also called certificates of naturalization). Early naturalization laws allowed any "court of record" (municipal, county, state, or federal) to grant United States citizenship and did not even require courts to issue certificates.
Without statutory instruction or administrative oversight, certificates of citizenship/naturalization issued prior to September 27, 1906, varied in size, shape, and design based on the clerk of court’s preference. The certificate’s contents also varied between courts with many omitting biographical information.
Many early certificates of citizenship/naturalization were simply certified copies of the court orders conferring United States citizenship. By the mid-19th century, naturalization courts often provided more elaborate, pre-printed documents, but the quality and appearance of certificates of citizenship/naturalization continued to vary significantly.
Early certificates did not include important biographical information or security features. Without centralized content control, naturalization records often contained little more than the applicant’s name, the names of witnesses, and the country to which they renounced allegiance. Many courts’ certificates did not include a description of the person naturalized and were consequently easily transferable. The variation and absence of biometric information and security features made authenticating certificates of naturalization difficult, facilitating fraud.
Additionally, many certificates omitted names of family members who derived United States citizenship from the primary subject’s naturalization. Due to this, a large number of legitimate citizens are unnamed in the court records documenting their naturalization.
Courts did not keep copies of “Old Law” certificates of citizenship/naturalization as insurance against loss of the original certificate by the naturalized citizen and/or destruction of the naturalization court’s records. The lack of provision for backup copies of naturalization records left both citizens and the government vulnerable to regional disasters which destroyed local court records. For example, the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and subsequent fire destroyed the city’s courthouses and homes. Many naturalized citizens' proof of citizenship burned, putting their rights as citizens in jeopardy, and the federal government faced many false claims to United States citizenship from persons claiming their naturalization prior to the catastrophe.
By the late 1800s, the effect of courts individually administering naturalization laws was evident in large numbers of naturalization fraud cases across the nation. The lack of uniformity in courts’ procedures and recordkeeping practices were factors in the problem, so Congress took steps to exert more control over the content, format, and issuance of certificates of citizenship/naturalization.
“Certificate File (C-File)” period (September 27, 1906–March 31, 1956)
Congress passed the Basic Naturalization Act of 1906 to correct deficiencies in “Old Law” certificates of citizenship/naturalization (and many other problems with the early naturalization system). The law took effect September 27, 1906, founding the federal Naturalization Service, inaugurating the “Certificate File (C-File)” period, and transforming naturalization recordkeeping.
The Basic Naturalization Act of 1906 was Congress’ first real attempt at federal supervision of naturalization. It also marked the first time that the administration of the certificate of citizenship/naturalization was specified by federal law. Beginning September 27, 1906, federal laws and regulations – enforced by an administrative oversight agency with stringent penalties for violations – required that all naturalization courts nationwide:
- Issue a certificate of citizenship (also called certificate of naturalization) to every naturalized person (and name all members of the primary subject’s family who derived citizenship from the naturalization);
- Create certificates of citizenship/naturalization using standard forms distributed by the Naturalization Service which controlled the content, format, and quality of the records;
- Submit a duplicate copy of every certificate of citizenship/naturalization to the Naturalization Service for filing in a Certificate File (C-File); and
- Only issue replacement or duplicate certificates with approval of the Naturalization Service.
These innovations achieved federal supervision of the courts’ naturalization activities. Standard forms imposed uniformity on certificates of citizenship/naturalization issued on or after September 27, 1906, and collection of duplicates ensured a backup copy of certificates existed as protection against the loss of personal copies and/or courthouse records. Security features and uniform rules for issuing and replacing certificates also allowed the government to control, authenticate, and track certificates in circulation, increasing the records’ reliability as proof of identity and naturalization.
Every person naturalized between September 27, 1906, and March 31, 1956, has a Certificate File (C-File) with the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) (successor of the Immigration and Naturalization Service [INS]) containing a copy of their certificate of citizenship/naturalization. When the Naturalization Service received the duplicate copy of a certificate of naturalization, it opened a unique C-File to hold the new citizen’s naturalization records.
The Naturalization Service distributed three versions of its standard form certificate of citizenship/naturalization during the “Certificate File (C-File)” period (1906–1956):
Select "+" to display more information:
Researching Certificates of Citizenship/Naturalization
In most cases, the National Archives will not have a copy of the certificate of citizenship/naturalization. Two copies of the certificate were created after September 26, 1906 – one given to the petitioner as proof of citizenship, and one forwarded by the courts to the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS).
Certificates of citizenship/naturalization were issued by the federal courts until October 1991 when naturalization became an administrative function under the INS.
INS records are now overseen by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). USCIS maintains duplicate copies of naturalization records (including certificates) created September 27, 1906–March 31, 1956 within Certificate Files (C-Files). Beginning April 1, 1956, INS began filing all naturalization records in a subject’s Alien File (A-File). C-Files can be requested through the USCIS Genealogy Program.
If you are a naturalized citizen seeking your own documentation, you can place a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to USCIS to obtain a copy of your records and/or request a replacement certificate of citizenship from USCIS.