2026 Annual Open Meeting Transcript
Tuesday, August 4, 2026
10:00 a.m. (ET)
Virtual Event
William Fischer: William Fischer, Executive for Agency Services here at the National Archives and Records Administration. Welcome to the 10th annual public meeting of the Office of Government Information Services, OGIS. Ten years ago Congress passed the FOIA Improvement Act of 2016 mandating, among other things, that OGIS have an annual public meeting. This meeting gives OGIS the yearly opportunity to highlight the work it does as the FOIA Ombuds, helping requesters and federal agencies navigate the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) process.
The meeting also gives interested individuals the opportunity to present oral or written statements. It is fitting that this year's meeting falls in the first week of August. The United States Senate, on August 3rd, 2007, passed by unanimous consent, an early version of the Openness Promotes Effectiveness in our National Government Act of 2007, better known as the OPEN Government Act of 2007. The bill, reintroduced in the Senate in December 2007 and co-sponsored by a bipartisan group of 18 Senators, was signed into law by President George W. Bush on December 31, 2007. The bill established OGIS within the National Archives. Two years later the FOIA Ombuds opened its doors for business. In advocating for the bill on the Senate floor, 19 years ago this week, Senator Patrick Leahy said open government and transparent decision making are bedrock American values.
Each day OGIS works with requesters and agencies to bring about shared understanding of and mutual respect for the FOIA process. OGIS plays a unique role in the FOIA landscape as it resolves disputes through impartial assistance and reviews agency FOIA practices to identify opportunities for systemic improvement. I'm proud of the work OGIS does to advocate for a fair and efficient FOIA process for all: requesters and agencies alike. I now turn the meeting over to OGIS director Alina Semo to update on OGIS's activities for the last fiscal year.
Alina M. Semo: Thank you, Bill, I really appreciated you being with us this morning. Good morning everyone my name is Alina Semo and as the director of the Office of Government Information Services or OGIS, the FOIA Ombuds, it is my pleasure to welcome all of you to our 10th annual open meeting. I hope everyone who is joining us today has been staying safe, healthy and well. In a minute I will go through some basic housekeeping rules and set some expectations for today's meeting, but first some background on why we are holding this virtual meeting today.
As Bill alluded early in 2016 Congress passed the FOIA Improvement Act which mandated that OGIS, not less frequently than annually, “conduct a meeting that is open to the public on the review and reports on the office.” Congress also tasked OGIS with “allowing interested persons to appear and present oral, written statements at the meeting.” So that's what we will be doing today. But we also have a very exciting program coming up. Next slide, please.
So first a thank you to the audio-visual team at the National Archives for live streaming this meeting on the National Archives YouTube channel and for their behind the scenes support we are eternally grateful, we can't do it without you and very much appreciate all of your support. Also a big thank you to my NARA colleagues, without whom today's meeting would not be possible.
Following my year in review presentation and our exciting panel presentation, we will have a public comment period. During the public comment period we will allow interested registered callers the opportunity to comment orally. As we noted in our Federal Register notice, each caller will be limited to three minutes each. I want to note that if you are watching us on the NARA YouTube channel, you will not be able to provide oral comments during our public comment period. However, you are welcome to submit written comments or statements, we are accepting public written comments for 30 days
following today's meeting through Wednesday, September 3rd. Please use our public comments form available at www dot archives dot gov forward slash public dash comments. We will post all comments that meet our posting policy, which is available on the website I just noted. While we are happy to have all points of views shared, please respect your fellow attendees and keep the conversation civil and on topic. We are recording today's session and we will post a transcript of this event on the OGIS website as soon as it becomes available. A video of this meeting will be accessible for later viewing on the NARA YouTube channel.
OK. That concludes our housekeeping, let's go to the next slide please. And let's get started. But before we delve into our Fiscal Year 2025 report, FY2025, let me first provide a brief introduction to our office for those of you who are joining us and don't know very much about our office. As the federal government’s FOIA ombuds we help agencies and requesters resolve disputes, improve FOIA administration, and identify opportunities to strengthen transparency and public trust. Congress created OGIS in the Open Government Act of 2007 and we opened our doors in September 2009. OPEN by the way stands for Openness Promotes Effectiveness in our National Government, a great acronym.
This slide that you see before you now is a summary of all the ways in which OGIS fulfills its legislative mandate and much, much more. Since 2009, OGIS has served as a neutral and trusted resource for both FOIA request requesters and federal agencies, helping to bridge different perspectives and improve the administration of FOIA government wide. Everything you'll hear about today flows directly from the responsibilities Congress assigned to OGIS in the FOIA statute. We provide mediation services to resolve FOIA disputes. We review agencies FOIA policies, procedures and compliance. And we identify procedures and methods for improving FOIA compliance. Through all of our activities we serve as a neutral and trusted resource for both FOIA requesters and federal agencies, helping to bridge different perspectives and improve the administration of FOIA government wide. Today I am going to focus on the review and reports of the office as Congress mandated, but also touch upon some of the other ways in which we fulfill our statutory mandate. And later this morning we will hear about the work of the FOIA Advisory Committee, whose work helps OGIS fulfill its statutory mandate to identify procedures and methods for improving compliance with the FOIA. Next slide, please. Thanks.
So I very much appreciate the opportunity to share with all of you highlights from our Fiscal Year 2025 Annual Report. We published our ‘26 Annual Report for FY25 at the end of May, like all of our annual reports, it is available on the OGIS website and we invited you to go visit and take a look at this year's report as well as previous reports. This report, submitted to Congress and the President as required under the FOIA statute, reflects a year of significant change across the federal FOIA landscape. Some agencies experienced significant workforce reductions, many experienced FOIA professionals left government service, and both incoming requests and agency backlogs increased substantially. Throughout that period OGIS remained a study neutral resource for both requesters and agencies. We provided timely dispute resolution services, conducted meaningful compliance work, supported government-wide leadership through the Chief FOIA Officers Council and FOIA Advisory Committee and identified practical opportunities to improve FOIA administration across the government. The report reflects an office that continued to fulfill its dual statutory mission - dispute resolution and compliance. Next slide, please.
This chart highlights the sustained growth in OGIS’s dispute resolution workload for over the past nine fiscal years. Beginning in fiscal year 2023, OGIS experienced a significant increase in requests for assistance and that higher demand has persisted through fiscal year 2025. Last year alone OGIS received 6,061 requests for assistance and we closed 6,088 cases, meaning we closed more cases than we received for the third consecutive year. These numbers reflect both the increased demand for OGIS’s services and our ongoing commitment to providing timely, effective assistance to requesters and agencies despite operating with a small staff. In fiscal year 2025 we closed 99% of our cases within 90 days. Next slide, please.
In fiscal year 2025, OGIS completed its first compliance assessment required by Congress under the Cleland-Dole Act focusing on the Department of Veteran Affairs (VA) FOIA program. We conducted a comprehensive review that included a statistically significant sample of FOIA requests, interviews with VA personnel, a survey of FOIA professionals and an examination of policies, procedures and organizational practices. The assessment identified several opportunities to strengthen FOIA administration, particularly with respect to first-party request processing, customer communications, organizational consistency, technology, and data quality. Based on a total of 10 findings OGIS issued 15 practical recommendations to help VA improve the efficiency, consistency and transparency of its FOIA program. We published the report on our website on September 26th, 2025 and I invite everyone to go and take a look at it. This assessment illustrates OGIS unique statutory role as an independent collaborative partner that helps agencies identify systemic issues and strengthen FOIA administration through objective evidence-based recommendations. Next slide, please.
Each year our NARA colleagues in the Office of Chief Records Officer or CRO distribute a questionnaire to assess whether federal agencies are complying with statutory and regulatory records management requirements. The response rate from agencies has been quite impressive over the years hovering at or above 95%. Since 2016 our colleagues have graciously invited OGIS to include several questions about FOIA administration and we very much appreciate their continued welcome and participation of OGIS in the survey. Because effective records management is the foundation of effective FOIA administration, our assessment examined government-wide trends, strengths and areas where agencies continue to face challenges. Our analysis identified opportunities for agencies to strengthen records management practices that ultimately support better records retrieval, improved compliance and more efficient responses to FOIA requests. This work reflects OGIS broader commitment to identifying systemic issues and sharing government-wide observations that help agencies improve transparency and information management. Next slide, please.
One area our report recognizes is the change that took place in the federal FOIA workplace landscape. These next two slides that I'll be sharing with you are related. The first looks at changes in agency FOIA staffing and the second shows what happened to agency backlogs. While staffing is certainly not the only factor affecting FOIA performance the two charts together illustrate many of the challenges agencies faced during fiscal year 2025. This chart shows the percentage change in full-time FOIA staffing across the CFO (Chief FInancial Officer) Act agencies between fiscal year 2024 and fiscal year 2025. As you can see, many agencies experience reductions in dedicated FOIA staff during the year, while a smaller number reported increases. These staffing changes occurred during the period when agencies managed increasing FOIA workloads and evolving operational challenges. The data underscores the importance of ensuring that agencies have the workforce and resources needed to administer FOIA effectively. Next slide, please.
This chart shows how agency FOIA backlogs changed between fiscal year, sorry between the end of fiscal year 2024 and the end of fiscal year 2025 while several agencies made meaningful progress reducing our backlogs many experienced increases and some quite substantial. Backlogs are influenced by many factors including request volume, request complexity, staffing levels, available resources and agency priorities. Taken together with the previous slide this data provides important context for the challenges many federal FOIA programs faced during fiscal year 2025 and reinforces the importance of continued attention to resources, process improvements and technology to strengthen FOIA administration, government wide. Next slide, please.
One of the benefits of serving as the federal FOIA Ombuds is that OGIS has a unique government-wide perspective. Through our dispute resolution program, OGIS often observes and examines interactions between requesters and agencies across the federal government and notes common questions and issues that arise in the FOIA process. The FOIA Ombuds Observer aims to address questions and issues frequently seen in our individual cases. Our goal is to increase efficiency and transparency in the FOIA process. During fiscal year 2025 we published two observers addressing issues we have seen across government and hearing directly from both agencies and requesters. The first focused on a topic we’ve covered several times in the past, Estimated Dates of Completion or EDCs, explaining why accurate EDCs are important to requesters and how challenges with EDCs often reflect broader FOIA processing issues. The 2007 amendments to the FOIA require agencies to establish a
telephone line or online service that provides requesters with status information, including the date on which the agency originally received the request and “an estimated date on which the agency will complete action on the request.” OGIS has observed that the statute challenges many agencies. OGIS continues to work to address this individual challenge by helping individuals who seek assistance, frequently reminding agencies of their responsibility to provide EDCs when requested, publishing resources and holding space for important conversations about EDCs.
We also published a second FOIA Ombuds Observer, using FOIA to Access Intelligence Community Records, to provide practical guidance for individuals seeking access to intelligence community records and helping to navigate one of the more complex areas of the FOIA process. These publications are one way OGIS fulfills its statutory mission to improve FOIA by identifying common challenges and sharing practical government-wide guidance. I invite all of you to please go visit the links that are provided on this slide. Next slide, please.
So looking ahead, just very briefly, OGIS remains focused of course on continuing to fulfill both aspects of our statutory mission, dispute resolution and compliance and we will continue as we have since 2009 to provide neutral and expert assistance to requesters and agencies seeking our assistance in navigating the FOIA process. I do want to highlight two assessments our compliance team is working on with the goal of publication by the end of this fiscal year. First, the team is updating an assessment of agency FOIA websites from November 2022. For our 2022 assessment we reviewed FOIA websites for all 15 cabinet level departments including their components and six independent agencies. For each site OGIS reviewed the presence or absence of 25 criteria that reflect OIP guidance, Office of Information Policy at the Department of Justice and FOIA Advisory Committee best practices for FOIA websites. Fast forward to this year, our compliance team is revisiting and updating that assessment, although it is more limited in nature, we are looking at FOIA websites again for 25 agencies, the 15 cabinet level agencies and nine independent agencies designated by the Chief Financial Officers Act of 1990, the CFO Act, plus the National Archives. So please be on the lookout for that report on our website by the end of this fiscal year. Also, please be on the lookout again for OGIS Records Management Self- Assessment, RMSA report based on questions we asked in this past years RSNA. Next slide, please.
I'd like to pause and recognize the extraordinary work of the OGIS staff. We describe ourselves as a small but mighty team and this past year demonstrated exactly why. Despite an increasingly complex FOIA landscape the OGIS team remains steadfast in its commitment to public service. Every OGIS staff member contributed in meaningful ways, whether by thousands of requesters and agencies through our dispute resolution program, conducting compliance, supporting the Chief FOIA Officers Council and the FOIA Advisory Committee, delivering training, engaging with stakeholders or identifying practical opportunities to strengthen FOIA administration across the government. What makes me most proud is not simply what we accomplished, but how we accomplished it.
The OGIS staff approaches every interaction with professionalism, integrity, empathy and an unwavering commitment to neutrality. They listen carefully, treat everyone with respect and work tirelessly to earn the trust of both requesters and agencies. Trust that is essential to our role as the federal FOIA ombuds. Together this small but mighty team continues to advance NARA's vision of a shared commitment to openness and transparency by promoting access to federal records, strengthening FOIA administration and helping ensure that the FOIA process works fairly, effectively and as Congress intended. I could not be more proud of this team or more grateful for their dedication, professionalism, resilience and commitment to public service. To every member of the OGIS team: Martha, Carrie, Kirsten, Sheela, Jessie, Kimberlee, Dan, Amber, and Teresa - thank you, it is a privilege to serve with you. Everything we’ve highlighted in this annual report is a reflection of your hard work, expertise and unwavering commitment to the mission of OGIS. And everything I've highlighted this morning reflects OGIS’s commitment to serving as a trusted resource dedicated to strengthening the administration of FOIA across the federal government. So with that I will turn things over to Kirsten at this point in our morning meeting. Kirsten, over to you and next slide, please.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Thank you, Alina and welcome everyone. I'm Kirsten Mitchell and among the hats I wear at OGIS is as the Designated Federal Officer or DFO for the FOIA Advisory Committee. As DFO I manage and administer the Committee so it can, as noted in the charter, effectively conduct its business. We at OGIS see the work of the FOIA Advisory Committee as dovetailing very nicely with the mandate in the FOIA statute that tasks OGIS to identify procedures and methods for improving FOIA compliance. I am thrilled to have three Advisory Committee members here with us today to discuss the Committee and its important work. They are Shelley Kimball of Johns Hopkins University, Frank LoMonte of CNN and Alina Semo, who needs no introduction, in addition to directing OGIS Alina also chairs the FOIA Advisory Committee. I'll quickly introduce Frank and Shelley and then I'll jump right into questions.
Frank is Newsroom Legal Counsel for CNN where he advises the network 3,000 worldwide journalists on legal issues that arise in gathering and distributing the news. He has three decades of experience with freedom of information law as a journalist, a leader in the non-profit advocacy field, an academic researcher, and a practicing attorney. As a journalist Frank's use of federal FOIA to break multiple stories about fraud in the home care industry sparked his interest in the equalizing power of freedom of information laws to help citizens level the playing field between themselves and their government.
Frank served on both the Statutory Reform Subcommittee and the Implementation Subcommittee, two of the three subcommittees established for the 2024 to 2026 term.
Shelley is Associate Program Director and Senior Lecturer in communication at Johns Hopkins University where she teaches communication regulation, media affects and qualitative research methods. Shelley’s research focus is on practical application of open government provisions, specifically at the intersection between requester and access professionals with an eye towards tempering any animosity between requesters and access professionals. She has taught media law for 25 years at five universities and like Frank is a former journalist and often found herself explaining the law as she tried to access non-exempt information. Shelley served on the Volume and Frequency Subcommittee and led surveying and focus group efforts for the Committee, presenting research in three Committee meetings this term. Shelley and Frank both served on the working group that wrote the final report, along with Sarah Weicksel of the American Historical Association. Frank and Shelley, welcome. So I'm going to ask a series of questions. I think I'll start with you, Shelley. Can you talk a little bit about what being a member of the FOIA Advisory Committee entails?
Shelley Kimball: Well first of all, thank you so much. I'm so happy to be here with all of you. Being part of the FOIA Advisory Committee to me, as I look back on the previous term, was really being part of a team. In everything that we did we were kind of thinking of all the other members and how we all fit together as a big puzzle. One of the things that I found when we first started is we all come from different areas of expertise, different focus and priorities and so kind of bringing that all together as one cohesive group, was really rewarding.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Frank?
Frank LoMonte: Well I think, you know, to me it is all about the exchange of ideas across the aisle from people that habitually tend to see themselves as adversaries, right. The people that make the request and the people that process the request. And just to be able to put your swords down and to sit down for an hour a week and really brainstorm about how do we make this process work better for everybody, how do we make this a win/win and not a zero sum game where somebody has to win and somebody has to lose. That was really the intangible benefit above and beyond any of the 11 good recommendations that we're going to talk about.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Right, thank you. I love that, put your swords down. Very nice. This Committee term ended with 11 recommendations adding to 67 recommendations made in five previous terms and Frank, you noted in the Committee's final meeting just several weeks ago that if the Committee kept layering dozens and dozens more recommendations, FOIA professionals who are overworked and under appreciated would be overwhelmed to the point of turnoff. Given that recognition, which I think you all have pretty early on in this two year term, could you talk about the process of coming up with the recommendations?
Frank LoMonte: Yes and I would say first of all, we really viewed our role, I think, as taking of a baton pass from the last term’s Committee, [the] last term’s Committee wrote an especially excellent final report that set the table for us beautifully and one of the insights of that report was there are 67 recommendations, we are directing many of these to people who are already telling us that they are overwhelmed with their day jobs and here we are making more and more demands on them. And our goal was to make sure that people did not see the work of this Committee as burdensome or imposing on them new and different demands because the whole idea is to be a facilitator to what can we do to make your jobs easier, what can we do to make FOIA run more smoothly, not what can we do to worsen this already crushing workload you are under. I will say, Shelley is going to talk about this in a minute, she won't brag about this so I will, the central insight of this past two years was Shelley and our colleague Deborah Moore’s work on focus groups and discerning from the people who are in the trenches doing this all the time, just how overburdened that they feel and what they most need to succeed in their jobs and we'll talk more about that later on.
But knowing all that, right. Knowing, having that benefit of having a really powerful insight that Shelley and Deborah have just put together and having that baton pass from the last Committee, we really looked at it as what can we do to make the existing 67 recommendations more user friendly. And one of the things, I work with, one of our valued colleagues on the Committee, professor Richard Peltz-Steele on trying to come up with a taxonomy, if you organize these recommendations, which you'll find on the NARA, on the dashboard, the recommendations are organized chronologically, which makes a lot of sense as a historical record of the work of the Committee, but maybe is not the most user-friendly way for the people who are being asked to actually apply them. Once you actually start crunching them and organizing and putting them into a taxonomy, and that taxonomy appears as one of our appendices by the way, you find out only maybe about 22 of the 67 that are directed to agencies as opposed to being directed to other actors. Even among those 22 a lot of them are variations of the same recommendation. You know it is vanilla and French vanilla, right. So five of them, maybe six of them, were variations of we need to do something about the problem of first-person requests. This is loading up the FOIA docket with unnecessary work when people just need their own records. I need to get government benefits. I need to process my immigration petition, I’m going to have to go through the same FOIA process an investigative reporter would go through to get 20 years worth of emails, and that makes no sense. Once you really get down to crunching the numbers and looking at the way the recommendations fit together it is much less overwhelming, we can talk later about this too. One of our insights in this process was, can we task NARA and OGIS with coming up with a way to present these recommendations in a manner that invites people in as opposed to pushing them away?
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Right. Thank you. I just have two things I want to insert here, you mentioned Deborah Moore, Deborah Moore represented the Department of Education. You also mentioned professor Richard Peltz- Steele, who represented University of Massachusetts Law School.
So Shelley, Frank touched on this a little bit, but focus groups and past Committee members have conducted surveys that they shared with the Committee. I think that goes all the way back to the first term of the Committee. But this is the first term in which a member conducted focus groups. I'm really interested in why focus groups and what did you learn from focus groups that you couldn't of learned from a survey.
Shelley Kimball: Well, as a qualitative researcher I feel like qualitative research tells us the how and the whys of things, sort of the way to untangle a complicated problem. And so we have a complicated problem that has a lot of layers, a lot of nuance and none of us wanted to guess at what's going on. We knew that there were a series of really solid recommendations from previous Committees, but we can't quite tell whether they are being adopted and what we could do to maybe make it easier for agencies or FOIA professionals to adopt or implement our recommendations. So for me then I just wanted to go to the source and one of the best ways is through a focus group. We did conduct a survey in Volume and Frequency [Subcommittee] and they are super, I do surveys with open-ended questions where people can answer and kind of tell stories. This was more complicated than that.
And so what we find with focus groups is it is a really great way to have people come explain their experiences. We know not every agency responds in exactly the same process when managing FOIA requests or when implementing change within their offices and so having people just tell us how does it work where you are? What would make it easier for you to implement change? Having them have those conversations with us, but then more importantly with each other. In a focus group I always feel like there is this magic that happens in a great focus group where people start to talk to each other and start brainstorming together or reminding each other, oh yeah that happened to me and then we get to see a really greater vision of what's happening in our world. And so we were absolutely blown away by the participation in these groups, especially during a time where there was kind of some uncertainty and staffing issues. We had sent out requests just for participation, kind of explaining what we were doing and we had almost 80 people end up participating in these focus groups. So we ran them in a series where we did maybe five or so people at a time. We listened and took handwritten notes just to make sure that they felt very safe, kind of sharing what's going on within their agencies.
We learned so much. Even in every one focus group we came back with so many ideas. We rotated people as moderators and notetakers so people beyond me, Sarah, Deborah, Rick, Frank, got a chance to take notes and every time someone sent me their notes they were telling me how excited they were, they learned so much, so many new ideas and that to me is what a focus group does is teaches us so much that we can't possibly learn, because we're not in those agencies. And so we came back with a lot of surprises, things that we didn't consider. We came back also understanding that access professionals aren't necessarily using our recommendations. And maybe it is because they don't know where to find them or it is an overwhelming list. So I'm really proud of what the Implementation [Subcommittee] subgroup did this term in making very practical changes and ideas to the process. Like Frank mentioned, just sort of categorizing, reordering, and we'll talk more about recommendations, but also a big surprise to us was when we got into these focus groups the participants needed time to just talk to each other. Like beyond the data gathering, beyond the research, beyond the moderating and note taking they just needed to chat and so we found that just having that sort of fellowship, comparing notes, was hugely important. We had in fact people signing up for the focus groups only for that part to meet other access professionals. And so that uncovered a need on its own for us.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Great, thank you. And both you and Frank have mentioned the recommendation to OGIS that we sort of organize the dashboard in a friendlier way so that it just focuses on those recommendations that are geared for FOIA professionals. I think Alina has noted this before, and I'll reiterate it, we are committed to doing that. So Frank, I'm going to ask you this question about the recommendations to Congress. Because there are 11 recommendations and seven of them are to Congress, that's two-thirds. That's larger than we've ever had in the past. Why so many and how would FOIA change if Congress were to pass these recommendations?
Frank LoMonte: Well again I think you go back to the insights gleaned from the focus groups and the discussions with stakeholders. And one of the things that came across loud and clear to us is that people working on the frontlines of FOIA feel empowered only to do so much. There is only so much that is within their ability and their capacity to do. And so, once we recognize that and we acknowledge that look you can only tell the people who are already underresourced and overworked in so many different ways - here is how to do your job better, here is how to do your job better before they tune you out. It became important for us really to look outward and say what's the elephant in the room here, why is it so difficult for people to turn around these requests on a timely basis. Why is it so difficult for somebody in my position as a representative of the news media, to get anything answered anywhere close to within the statutory deadline and the answers always kept pointing back to Congress.
And so you ask how would FOIA change, dramatically, I will just point to two of the recommendations focused to Congress that would represent and seachange in the way FOIA operates if implemented. One, is the funding formula recommendation. People have struggled with this for so long to figure out, well how do you make FOIA a priority for agencies that are pulled and tugged in so many different directions with so many competing priorities for money and staffing. And the answer has to be to lock in some kind of a formula, so that there is a relationship between the demand for the agency service and the funding level and the staffing level. We know where the backlogs are, we know where the problems are, we know where the habitual clogs in the pipeline are and it is possible to address that with more resources but that starts to committing in the appropriation process. Coming up with a formula that is actually calculated to dig our way out of the backlog and then keep another one from accumulating.
And so the funding formula is really important and then there's this kind of stealth one that snuck in one line in the report but it's a very mighty line, which is creation of a FOIA court. There is a lot of interest in trying to figure out ways to expedite the judicial review and people on the bench in the DC courts in particular have been crying out for relief because they disproportionately absorb the weight of FOIA litigation. And by creating an expert bench and we certainly know how to do this, right, patent cases go to an expert bench, immigration courses go to an expert bench. Lots of cases that require specialized,
knowledge and expertise go to an expert bench. And a FOIA bench would have two benefits, first of all it would relieve the backlog burdening in particular the DC courts but make sure that people who have FOIA cases get those cases tried by somebody who is really invested in FOIA law, which is a niche specialty that almost nobody studies in law school, almost nobody does as full time practice. It would ensure those get the most expert possible eyes on them. And so just those two recommendations would be transformative of the way FOIA works and would make it work much more smoothly and much more quickly.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Right, thank you. So Alina, I’m going to pull you into the conversation if I may.
Alina M. Semo: I thought I was off the hook but apparently not.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: No. So one of the challenges of this Committee, as noted in the Committee’s final report is that there was an imbalance after four government members departed in the early days of 2025. You are a government member and the Committee’s Chair. How did you navigate that challenge?
Alina M. Semo: Kirsten, thanks for that question, it was definitely a challenge this past term. It was an unexpected challenge to have the departure of four government members within a relatively short period of time due to broader workforce transitions across the federal government that I discussed earlier. Those departures created an unfortunate imbalance in the Committee [audio and closed captioning lost] the middle of past term so we have been able to replace them with other nominees as we strive to maintain balanced representation among government and non-government members. We were unable to replace three of the members, but we were fortunate to be able to appoint the former director of OIP, Sean Glendening, for several months which helped reduce the vacancies from four to three.
From my perspective as the Chair, my responsibilities did not change. My role has always been to facilitate the Committee’s work fairly, ensure that every member has an opportunity to contribute and help the Committee build consensus, whenever possible. It is not always possible. I wasn't there to advocate for one perspective over another, but rather to make sure the Committee had the opportunity to do its best work. And fortunately the Committee members approach the situation with an extraordinary degree of professionalism and mutual respect. Even though the Committee's composition changed during the term, members remain committed to hearing different viewpoints, asking difficult questions, testing their ideas through thoughtful discussion. The government members that remained, and I'm thankful for their service, provided valuable operational perspectives, while the non-government members contributed equally important insights from the requester, academic, media and advocacy communities.
Despite these challenges I am very proud to say the Committee never lost momentum. We held every scheduled public meeting, except for one, September 2025 due to the government shut down. All three subcommittees and working groups met to advance their work. And the Committee completed its work on schedule. Most importantly, as we’ve already identified, we reached consensus on all 11 recommendations in a fabulous final report that Shelley and Frank helped coauthor and I really think that's a testament to everyone's dedication, professionalism and collaborative spirit. Every single Committee member contributed. To me that's one of the real success stories of the Committee despite an unusual period of transition, the members remained focused on what brought them together in the first place, which was to improve administration of FOIA for agencies, requesters, and the public and I am very grateful for everything the Committee members did this past term.
Kirsten Mitchell: Thank you. So I'm going to ask a question that's kind of like asking who is your favorite child, but I'll start with you, Shelley. Of the 11 recommendations from this term, which one is your favorite recommendation and why?
Shelley Kimball: It is so hard, because knowing all the work and thought that's gone into each one, and I have two, if I can have two….
Kirsten Mitchell: Sure.
Shelley Kimball: Because they both came straight from the research, straight from access professionals’ wishes. So that was super important to me to take what they were telling us and turn it into something tangible to help. And so we have one that was asking for agencies to review workloads and technology to make sure that staffing is in place, that they have the effective technology to be as efficient as possible. We did those focus groups just after, it was after the government shutdown but also after all of the staffing changes. And so we were in a huge state of flux, and so sort of capturing what would help climb over those growing backlogs and this is really something that was important to access professionals out in the field on the front lines and we heard this loud and clear both in the survey and in the focus group so that one was hugely important.
The other one that is hard for me to not recognize is the recommendation that a networking group be built for access professionals, only because it was sort of, it was such a discovery that it was not something we came in really even thinking about or considering, but it was something that they, the access professionals, really talked about and showed us when working with us in the data collection. Because it was such a surprise, and because the infrastructure is actually sitting waiting to help in this endeavor, that one to me seemed like kind of just a gift that we could pull that together also for those processing requests.
Kirsten Mitchell: Great, thank you. Frank, how about you? You mentioned the funding FOIA, funding formula recommendation and FOIA court, but do you have another favorite?
Frank LoMonte: I actually can't disagree with Shelley at all, having gotten a chance to sit in on a couple of those focus groups. I just love the camaraderie that I saw, the sense of community among the people that you could see sort of building right in front of your eyes, the idea of creating a vehicle by which people can sustain that energy and can build upon it and can exchange ideas and maybe just sometimes even commiserate, you know, something that has real value and that, you know, is a way to share best practices across agency silos, which too often we get into our own silos and we don't share our learning, we don't share what we know. I absolutely love that one. But I will say if I could pick only one to be acted upon, it would be the funding formula one only because that's the driver of everything else honestly. What everybody kept telling us was we just need more resources, we just need more resources and to be able to memorialize something that would guarantee people a stream of adequate resources would be the single greatest change that we could make in the FOIA process.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Great, thank you. Alina?
Alina M. Semo: So I'm going to pick a different one, even though all the recommendations reflect a tremendous amount of work the Committee members did. I guess I would pick my favorite one is the one that would make the FOIA Advisory Committee a non-discretionary federal advisory committee. For over a decade the Committee has demonstrated the value of bringing together government and non-government experts to tackle some of the most challenging issues we face in FOIA administration. A number of recommendations from prior terms have already been implemented in whole or in part. Many others continue to influence policy and practice, but making the Committee permanent would help ensure this collaborative forum continues to provide Congress, agencies and the FOIA community with thoughtful consensus based recommendations for the future. So that is definitely my favorite one.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Great, thank you. So I'm going to ask what challenges we'll face in the next term of the Committee. I know there's a good portion of the report that speaks to that and sort of looks ahead. But I'll start with you, Frank. What challenges do you foresee the next term having?
Frank LoMonte: Well in terms of challenges I don't think it's too much different from where we found ourselves. Which is to say that the joint challenges are, we are in an environment where FOIA offices are being asked to do more with less. And you just can't ignore that. You can't ignore the reality that this is the, these are the conditions under which people are working and trying their best to fulfill these requests and keep pace. And so that's just the water that we swim in. And the other is, you know, you mentioned the fact that almost two-thirds of this report is directed to Congress, but creating some constituency and some sense of urgency around FOIA has been just an existential challenge as long as there has been a FOIA, right. Almost nobody thinks of FOIA as, except maybe the people in this tiny room, think of FOIA as being their highest priority or their greatest concern, right. You know, nobody runs for President or nobody campaigns for the Senate saying I'm going to reform FOIA, it is just not a front of the agenda item. And trying to build some constituency for it, build some salience, raise the profile of this issue and these recommendations I think really is the challenge for this Committee and all iterations to follow.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Shelley?
Shelley Kimball: I'm absolutely in alignment there with Frank. We had a lot of uncertainty this session and I don't think, I don't see that changing any time soon. I think that we know that FOIA shops are understaffed that the process right now is more difficult than it has ever been and I think it will continue to be overshadowed by the logistics of just trying to get the requests processed. And I think that no matter what direction the next term goes in studying FOIA and trying to find those efficiencies you really can't get that far afield from the lack of resources. And so one of the other things is that in support and we heard this in the focus groups and in the surveys that support for FOIA really has to come from the top. I think that’s also why we were aiming at Congress so much this session and we want our government representatives to sustain that commitment to transparency and that takes time. And so I'm really excited to see what the next term does and I don't, like Frank, I don't see a lot of difference from ours to the next.
Kirsten Mitchell: Alina?
Alina M. Semo: Kirsten I'm sorry, was the question what challenges the next - challenges. OK.
Kirsten Mitchell: Yeah… what challenges…
Alina M. Semo: OK, So I want to make sure I'm answering the correct question. As Frank and Shelley have already identified, the FOIA landscape has been changing very rapidly. Agencies are continuing to manage increasing request volumes, growing backlogs, workforce constraints and also heightened expectations for public access to information. But I think the other thing we should touch on is emerging technologies, including obviously Al, artificial intelligence. Those present tremendous opportunities and new questions for FOIA administration. The next Committee hopefully will have an opportunity to explore how technology can improve efficiency while ensuring that transparency, accountability and public trust remain at the center of FOIA implementation. So I look forward to continuing the Al and other technology related discussions in addition to everything else we have identified today.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Great. So I am looking at the time and I think we need to wrap this up. But before I do I just wanted to give Frank and Shelley one last word. Anything you'd like to add or any, anything I should have asked and didn't ask?
Frank LoMonte: I'm going to take two or three last words.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: OK.
Frank LoMonte: So first of all I promised myself I wouldn't leave without emphasizing that in the final report we point people to the excellent subcommittee reports and we really view this as a seamless whole product. If you only read the final report, you're only getting half of the benefit or maybe even less. The final report is really almost a road map and an executive summary of the very substantive subcommittee reports. I saw one of our excellent subcommittee co-chairs Jason Baron was here, the subcommittees is really where all the work got done and we have to take our hats off and salute the co-chairs for those being the driving force in the two year process. So there is that.
The other is…in the concluding section of the final report we lay out some of the unfinished business just as we took the baton past from last year's term. We're trying to make a seamless baton to next year's term. And we emphasize to them one of the bits of business we got quite a bit down the road on, not quite to a consensus on, was really looking at the subject of comprehensive exemption reform. If you ask people in the news media field that I represent what the pain point is with FOIA it's not even close it’s the overuse of overbroad exemptions and so that really needs some sustain and study focus
And the last thing I would say, you know, Kirsten was reading my resume and every five years I completely throw my career in the toilet and change jobs. And so every time you change jobs, every time you change careers you look back immediately and think oh here’s five things I could have done better. And the minute we posted this report I thought here’s five things I could have done better. And one of those is I really think the report, henceforth going forward should always have a section that identifies questions for the academic research community. Because academic research is such a powerful tool and there are so many resources out there. So many excellent people, like Shelley, like Professor Peltz-Steele, like other researchers who have expertise in this area that need to be pointed to the questions most urgent to be answered. What are the exemption three statutes out there? The 99% of the floor of the ocean we haven't mapped yet, how do we not know what all the exemption three statutes are, we should know that. That's a question for academic searchers to answer. I would urge the next Committee, first of all to focus on exemption reform and second of all to focus on identifying those research questions and putting the ball on the tee for the research community.
Kirsten Mitchell: Great, thank you. Shelley, any last word?
Shelley Kimball: Yeah I appreciate that Frank reminded us about the subcommittee reports and I completely agreed they are filled with a wealth of information from all three subcommittees. One thing I neglected to mention that I wanted to share was that in our focus groups we learned that access professionals were using some of these recommendations as leverage for change within their own organizations to say oh look here it is on paper. I feel like we left a huge trail of possibility, in all of these subcommittee reports in the final reports for the next term, for access professionals to use to find their own pathways forward as well.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Thank you. Alina, did you have any last word on this panel?
Alina M. Semo: Yeah I have many last words, but I just, this is a great opportunity for me just to reiterate how continually impressed I was by the dedication of our Committee members this term. This is volunteer service, on top of everyone's full time day jobs yet members consistently devoted countless hours to researching, drafting recommendations and engaging in very thoughtful discussion.
I was also struck by the Committee's resilience. We had lots of challenges, we didn't anticipate. Including significant changes affecting the federal workforce and agency operations and yet we remained focused on our mission and we successfully completed an ambitious body of work. Which I agree with Shelley, is represented not only by the Committee report, by the excellent subcommittee reports. So we definitely want to encourage everyone to look at all three of them. Four of them, three subcommittee reports and a final report.
I just want to say it was just incredibly rewarding to be chair of this particular Committee, I just got to witness firsthand discussion, compromise, collaboration, there was lots of consensus building that definitely happened. But that's definitely the strength of the FOIA Advisory Committee. So it was my honor to serve as Chair of this term and I'm very grateful for everyone's commitment and service and contributions this term. Thanks.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Well thank you Frank and Shelley and Alina. Thank you so much for this conversation. I wish we had a bit more time, but as Frank said there are only a small group of us in this room, who could go on and on and on about this for a long time. It was a joy working with you on the 2024 to 2026 term of the Committee and I hope we will have the opportunity to work together in the future. And Alina, I am going to turn things back over to you. So thank you.
Alina M. Semo: All right thank you Frank, Shelley, we really appreciate your time today and your contributions, thank you. And thank you Kirsten, as always a fabulous moderator. Next slide, please.
Oh this is a good slide, the full Advisory Committee report can be found at this link and we do invite everyone to take a look and as I mentioned also please take a look at the subcommittee reports, which are also on our website under the FOIA Advisory Committee’s 2024 to 2026 term. Next slide I believe is a slide of our FOIA Advisory Committee recommendations dashboard. That dashboard will need to be updated; it is currently not yet updated with 11 new recommendations, but OGIS will be doing that in the not too distant future. So please check back in to the dashboard and we will have those up there as soon as possible. And next slide, please.
So we have now reached the public comments part of our annual meeting. As I mentioned earlier, Congress has instructed us that in conducting our public meeting on the review and reports by the office, we shall allow interested persons to appear and present oral or written statements at the meeting. If you are watching us on the
National Archives YouTube channel we are happy you have joined us, but unfortunately you will not be able to provide oral comments. However, as a reminder, we will accept written public comments for the next 30 days through Wednesday, September 3rd. Please visit www dot archives dot gov forward slash OGIS forward slash public dash comments to submit written comments.
As we noted in our Federal Register Notice, each individual caller will be limited to three minutes each. An important reminder, with regard to oral comments, please be aware this is not the right time or venue to ask questions about a specific FOIA request or specific issue you are experiencing that is unique to you. And while we are happy to have all points of view shared, please remember to respect your fellow attendees and keep the conversation civil and on topic. So with that I will turn things over to my NARA colleague who will assist in providing access to anyone wishing to make a public statement at this time.
Christine? I just want to make sure you are on.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Alina, this is Kirsten, do you need me to step in?
Alina M. Semo: Sure, if you want to go through the instructions about how to dial in, yeah that would be great. Thank you.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Okay. Let me just go ahead and do this. So callers on the Zoom call, you can raise your hand with the raise hand icon on the lower screen and I will unmute you if you would like to make a comment. If you are dialed in through telephone audio you can press star 9 on your telephone to raise your hand and join the comment queue. Once you are unmuted please state your name and affiliation and you will be given three minutes to speak. Okay.
Alina M. Semo: Thank you Kirsten, I appreciate that.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: Sure.
Alina M. Semo: I don't see anyone with hands raised yet, maybe we need to give people a few minutes to collect their thoughts because we presented a lot of information today.
Kirsten B. Mitchell: We did. I do not see any hands raised. Nor do I see any traffic in the chat.
Alina M. Semo: Why don't we give folks maybe one or two more minutes in case they are still collecting their thoughts. Don't be shy out there, our attendees, but no pressure at the same time. Kirsten, no one is raising their hands, I don't see anyone raising their hands and you don't hear anyone try to go dial in, correct?
Kirsten B. Mitchell: I don't.
Alina M. Semo: Okay, well we have certainly given the opportunity for folks to contribute orally. Again we certainly welcome any written comments that can be submitted until September 3rd, I have already given the website information and I think we're ready to wrap up our meeting, Kirsten. We can go to the next slide, please.
So since there are no further comments, we will wrap up our meeting early. I will give everyone back the gift of time. We had advertised this meeting would last until noon, everyone gets back about 45 minutes, please use it wisely. I want to thank all of you who have joined us for our annual open meeting today. I want to in particular thank Frank LoMonte and Shelley Kimball for joining us today and sharing their insights and representing the rest of the Committee members and representing a fabulous term that we had with 11 recommendations from the FOIA Advisory Committee.
I want to invite everyone to make sure you read our annual report and all of our excellent publications on our website. And we want you to keep in touch with us. So there are a variety of ways for you to do that. We invite you to subscribe to our blog, the FOIA Ombuds, and follow us on X and we hope that you will be following us and tracking everything that we're doing and checking back on our website for updates to our FOIA Advisory Committee dashboard as well as other publications. So with that I want to thank everyone for joining us today and I hope everyone has a great rest of your summer and we will see you, hopefully again later this fall. Take care everyone.